Writing a murder mystery novel can be a thrilling endeavor, full of twists, suspense, and complex characters. Drawing from advice provided by seasoned mystery writers, here’s a guide to help you plan and write your own captivating murder mystery.

Plot Structure

Begin with the Crime

Start by outlining the central crime; this is the linchpin of your story. The crime should be intriguing enough to captivate readers from the outset.

Red Herrings and Twists

Incorporate misleading clues and unexpected plot twists to keep readers guessing. Properly executed red herrings can lead your readers down the wrong path while still playing fair with them.


Maintain a balance between fast-paced action scenes and slower, introspective moments. This ensures that readers stay engaged while having time to process the clues you’ve planted.


Ensure a satisfying resolution where all loose ends are tied up, and the mystery is clearly solved. Readers should feel a sense of closure after the climax of your story.

Character Development

Complex Characters

Develop multi-dimensional characters, including the detective, suspects, and the victim. Each character should have a compelling backstory and motivations that add depth to the narrative.

Backstory and Motivation

Provide compelling backgrounds and motives for all key characters. This makes them more relatable and the mystery more intricate.

Evolving Detective

Allow your detective to evolve with the story, showcasing their personal struggles and growth. This added layer of complexity can make your story more engaging.

Setting and Atmosphere

Atmospheric Descriptions

Use vivid descriptions to create a sense of place and mood, enhancing the mystery. The setting should feel tangible and contribute to the story’s overall tone.

Location as a Character

Treat the setting as an integral part of the story that shapes the events and tone. A well-crafted setting can add an extra layer of tension and atmosphere.

Clues and Evidence

Logical Clues

Ensure clues are logical and can be pieced together by an attentive reader. Each clue should lead logically to the next, crafting a coherent path to the resolution.


Skillfully use foreshadowing to hint at future events without giving too much away. This technique can ramp up the suspense and reward readers who pick up on your subtle hints.

Investigation Techniques

Research modern and traditional investigation techniques to add realism to your story. Details about forensic science and police procedures make your story more believable.

Suspense and Tension

Building Suspense

Gradually build suspense through cliffhangers, timed revelations, and character reactions. Keep readers on the edge of their seats, eager to find out what happens next.

Emotional Engagement

Engage readers emotionally by creating high-stakes situations and moral dilemmas. When readers care about your characters, the tension feels more real.

Writing Style

Narrative Voice

Choose an appropriate narrative voice (first-person, third-person, etc.) that suits your story. The perspective can significantly affect how readers connect with your characters and plot.

Dialogue and Inner Thoughts

Use dialogue and inner monologues to reveal character traits and move the plot forward. Well-crafted dialogue can add layers to your characters and provide vital clues.

Editing and Revising

Polish your draft through rigorous editing, focusing on plot coherence, character consistency, and eliminating plot holes. A well-edited manuscript is crucial for maintaining reader engagement.

Research and Realism

Police Procedures and Legal Aspects

Familiarize yourself with police procedural details and legal implications to ensure accuracy. This research grounds your story in reality and makes it more believable.

Historical Context

If writing a historical mystery, immerse yourself in the era’s details to add authenticity. Accurate period details can enrich your story and transport readers to another time.

Tips from Seasoned Writers

Outline Your Story

Create a detailed outline before you start writing to map out key events, character arcs, and clues. This roadmap can guide you through the writing process and help maintain consistency.

Invest in Pre-Writing Research

Spend ample time researching the genre, forensic science, and settings to create a believable narrative. The more you know, the richer your story will be.

Write Regularly

Develop a consistent writing routine to maintain momentum and stay engaged with your story. Regular writing sessions can help you stay connected to your characters and plot.

Feedback and Critique

Seek feedback from fellow writers, editors, or beta readers to identify areas for improvement and enhance your story. Constructive criticism can help you refine your manuscript.

Reading Widely

Read extensively within the mystery genre to understand different styles, techniques, and common tropes. Learning from established authors can provide valuable insights and inspiration.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *